FAQ

-- What is in the book? Can I see the Table of Contents?
Table of Contents

The Author xiii
Note to the Reader xvii
Foreword by Morton C. Blackwell xxi
Acknowledgements xxviii
Introduction xxix

Part I

Chapter I
Resolving Prior Objections 3

Chapter II
The Universal Scope of the Allocutions to the Roman Patriciate and Nobility 17

Chapter III
The People and the Masses, Liberty and Equality: Wholesome Versus Revolutionary
Concepts in a Democratic Regime 25

Chapter IV
Nobility in a Christian Society—The Perennial Character of Its Mission and Its
Prestige in the Contemporary World 31

Chapter V
Elites, Natural Order, Family, and Tradition—Aristocratic Institutions Within
Democracies 49

Chapter VI
The Meaningful Contribution of the Nobility and Traditional Elites to the Solution
Of the Contemporary Crisis 67

Chapter VII
Genesis of the Nobility—Its Past and Present Mission 85

Conclusion
At the Apogee of Today’s Religious, Moral, and Ideological Crisis: A Propitious
Moment for the Action of the Nobility and the Traditional Elites 127

Part II

Appendix I
The United Sates: An Aristocratic Nation Within a Democratic State 136
Introduction 143

Chapter I
Social Stratification in the United States 145

Chapter II
Authentic and Inauthentic Elites 183

Chapter III
Sentimentalism: An Explanation for the Egalitarian Mentality 197

Chapter IV
The Juridical-Social Structure of Colonization 199

Chapter V
The Formation of a Colonial Aristocracy in Various Regions 217

Chapter VI
The American Revolution, Independence, and the Constitution 257

Chapter VII
The Republic up to the Civil War 279

Chapter VIII
The Elites After the Civil War 301

Chapter IX
Traditional Elites in Contemporary America 315

Epilogue
Lifting Our Gaze Toward the Alienated Elites 329

Appendix II
Genesis, Development, and Twilight of the “Nobility of the Land” in Colonial,
Imperial, and Republican Brazil 331
Introduction 333

Chapter I
How Elites Were Formed in Colonial Brazil 337

Chapter II
The Socioeconomic Cycles of Brazil and the History of the Nobility of the Land 349

Appendix III
The Revolutionary Trilogy—Liberty, Equality, Fraternity 381

Appendix IV
Forms of Government in the Light of the Church’s Social Doctrine 391

Appendix V
Aristocracy in the Thinking of a Controversial Twentieth-Century Cardinal Who
Cannot be Suspected of Bias in Its Favor 419

Part III

Documents I
Allocutions of Pius XII to the Roman Patriciate and Nobility 431

Documents II
Allocution of Benedict XV to the Roman Patriciate and Nobility on
January 5, 1920 463

Documents III
Special Duties of Society Toward the Impoverished Nobility 467

Documents IV
Noble Lineage: A Precious Gift of God 469

Documents V
The Church’s Doctrine on Social Inequalities 477

Documents VI
The Necessary Harmony Between Authentic Tradition and Authentic Progress 491

Documents VII
Ancient Rome: A State Born From Patriarchal Societies 495

Documents VIII
Feudalism: Work of the Medieval Family

Documents IX
The Familial Character of Feudal Government—The King: The Father
of His People 505

Documents X
The Paternal Character of the Traditional Monarchy 509

Documents XI
What Popes, Saints, Doctors and Theologians Think Regarding the Lawfulness
of War 513

Documents XII
Is Being Noble and Leading a Noble’s Life Incompatible With Sanctity? 519

Bibliography 525

Index 535
A. I would like to enter a Comment on one of the articles. How can I do this?
First, click the article that you wish to comment on. At the bottom of the post, where it says “Comments,” click either on the IntenseDebate icon on the right hand side, or, click where it says Login, right below “Comments.”

When the dialog box opens, if you have an IntenseDebate user, go ahead and log in. If you don’t, click on Create an Account.

On the registration page, give yourself a User Name and Password, and enter the email address you intend to use. Then, make sure the option for “I want to create an account to comment” has been checked, then click on Sign Up.

You are ready to make a comment on any posts. Just go back to the article and leave your comment.
B. Do you have an email list I can subscribe to? How can I receive future postings to the Blog?
We do have an email list that notifies those who subscribe every time the Blog is updated with new posts and stories. Just go to the Home Page and enter your email address. Once you click on the Subscribe button, a popup window appears and Feedburner will ask you to confirm your subscription by typing up the text you will see. When you receive a verification email, click the link to activate your subscription.
C. Can I see all of the blog's Short Stories together?
Sure, just click on the title of any Short Story, then click on the "Short Story" tag at the bottom of the story. Doing this pulls up all the stories on one page.
C. Does Nobility.org have a Comments Policy?
Comments Policy: Nobility.org reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone.

Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of Nobility.org.

Nobility.org will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages.

D. What are local elites?
“In its first sense, an elite is a group of fine persons who stand out as individuals from the mass of people constituting a community. Isolated individuals unrelated among themselves, do not constitute an elite. Rather, we speak of an elite only when its constituents interrelate with sufficient vitality and diligence so as to create a common primary psychological and intellectual milieu.
“An elite, therefore, is not a mere juxtaposition of preeminent persons. It is formed when such persons develop a relationship among themselves in which there is a mutual exchange of values. This relationship gradually constitutes a particular culture synthesizing the intellectual and moral values of all its members.
“This distillation is done especially through informal conversation. The persons who constitute an elite need not necessarily be drawn together by a concrete theme, but rather by an admixture of subjects introduced spontaneously through the art of good conversation. The result is a natural conviviality wherein each personality contributes to the development of an elite culture.
“This type of conversation broadens horizons in an unfettered atmosphere in which unexpected and unforeseen topics both appear and disappear. Such free mingling of ideas and impressions gives life to the conversation and constitutes the charm and cultural importance of this type of discussion, which is a cherished pastime among elites.
“Take, for example, a great diplomat, a renowned financial expert, an eminent writer, a distinguished doctor, and a prominent lawyer. Let us say these men gather once a month to converse for half an hour. This would be a group of eminent persons, but it would not constitute an elite.
“This group would constitute a true elite only if its members conversed more frequently and for longer periods of time—and without a fixed schedule. They might discuss various issues, exchanging ideas and values, which would ultimately create a specific atmosphere that gives rise to an elite culture.
“This exchange of ideas and values would be more complete and successful if the spouses of these men were to make up an informal social circle in which a similar process could take place. Spontaneity would provide authenticity for this type of relationship, which should be born freely from the natural interplay of human affairs.
“From this perspective, one can better understand the innate creativity of an elite. Only when it generates a way of thinking and a culture common to its constituents does it deserve to be called a true elite.
"This, then, is a first way to conceive of an elite: a group of people who constitute the best within their locality. They excel in their respective activities, which are also the most important activities, and they generate an elite culture through their informal social interrelations.
"A second, more restricted concept is that of an elite composed exclusively of those persons of exceptional importance who transcend the scope of the city's elect. They are an elite in another sense of the word. Small in number, they do not properly represent the cultural elite of the city, but rather transcend it....
“Consider a city which boasts a military academy, a theological institute, and an art school. The prominent people of the city entertain the higher academic staff of these schools in their homes, thus forming a local elite, whose conviviality, while not as elevated as [national elites], is analogous to it.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, pp. 183-184.)
E. What are National Elites? And International Elites?
“The elite of the nation is formed by people who excel at the national level. It is composed of exceptional figures of the nation, who are representative of its highest sectors of activity and who have corresponding relationships. Such an interrelation is manifested, for example, when a president invites outstanding figures in the fields of politics, economic, and culture to a ball or banquet at the White House.
"Most will not achieve international renown. Those who do achieve international stature, without ceasing to be the national elite, constitute within it, so to speak, an elite of elites." (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 184.)
F. What do you mean by "analogous traditional elites" ?
"Just as the development of social life in the Middle Ages led naturally to the formation of its historical nobility, later social processes legitimately gave rise to family lineages of long history and elevated culture in the fields of teaching, law, public administration, commerce, and industry. Through the process of social evolution these families and their descendants came to constitute a privileged body alongside the historical nobility in the nations of the West. They became, in a word, analogous elites.
"This form of nobility was neither military nor rural in origin, but rather of a cultural and administrative nature, rising from a hereditary tradition of public service or corporate leadership." (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, pp. 139-140.)
G. Is there a hierarchy among elites? How does an elitist society progress?
“A hierarchy is formed through this process. Beginning with local elites, it extends through successively higher circles to the most quintessential elites. This graduated and continuous scale of elites constitutes the structure of a healthy elitist society, wherein the highest circles develop a lifestyle and a human type that harmonically influence the lower levels.
"Historically, this is the type of elitist society formed in the West and in the mold of Christian civilization.
“This hierarchy implies two continual movements. One is in a vertical direction, whereby people of real merit can rise from one level to another. The other is in a horizontal direction, whereby people of the same level complement each other from moral, cultural, and other points of view. This double process attains a notable richness in countries with an authentically Christian civilization. This is because Christian charity, with its clearly supernatural mark, has a peerless efficacy in fraternally uniting men." (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, pp. 184-185.)
H. What is the difference between the elite and the upper class?
“The elite is the source of the upper class.
“Let us return to the example of a small city to facilitate understanding the difference between the two. As noted, the elite of a city is formed by those who exercise prestigious activities and who are preeminent within their fields. But this still does not necessarily constitute a social class.
“A social class is constituted when these individuals and their descendants acquire stability in their prominent positions. Such habitual eminence shapes them, and forms them into a single class. On the other hand, an elite is an informal group of individuals. We can only speak of a social class if the respective families also interrelate among themselves.
“In short the upper class is formed by a group of families who attained a certain degree of perfection by which they are molded and through which they became established.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 185.)
I. Can an elite be "traditional" without being "aristocratic?"
“A professional elite can be traditional without being aristocratic. It can, for example, be made up of the best fishermen who have practiced their profession along the New England coast for many generations.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 185.)
J. What makes an elite authentic?
“The authenticity of an elite, both traditional and aristocratic, comes from the excellence of its activities and lifestyle. It also arises from the fact that its members are truly what they claim to be.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 185.)
K. What is an "aristocratic elite?"
“An aristocratic elite is composed of members who exercise an activity compatible with the aristocratic condition. It must also be rooted in tradition, that is, to have existed for a period of time adequate to confer upon it a traditional character.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 185.)
L. Is refinement necessary for the development of elites?
“The previous considerations presuppose a process of refinement and cultivation of those persons and families who aspire to become members of the elite. Without this refinement, they can be rich, even very rich, but they will not be an authentic traditional elite.
“How does this process work? A man becomes rich, and a desire for prestige is born in him. To attain such prestige he feels the need to have certain noticeable qualities that distinguish him from the common man: more culture, better education, greater refinement, and the like. He feels the need to adopt a lifestyle that corresponds to the idea that the public has regarding what a man of prestige should be. Moved by this desire for prestige, he begins to refine himself according to this model.
“When this process of refinement began in the United States, American cultural life did not offer adequate national archetypes….
“Those aspiring to be part of the elite were obliged to imitate European models, principally English, the natural archetype for Americans. As a result, they thought that living in the manner of an English gentleman would confer social prestige. And since the English generally acknowledged the superiority of French fashions, the wives of these Americans began to adopt certain French styles in order to have prestige among the American public.
“In this way, rudimentary elites acquired in two or three generations an authenticity that made them capable of being assimilated by the older elites.
“In a well-constituted society, such a process of refinement would take place in all social classes, not just in the highest. For underneath this process lies man’s innate desire for perfection….
“In their journey toward perfection, the different classes naturally develop human types proper to each.” (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p.186.)
M. Are true elites developed today? Or was this development only possible in the past ?
"This organic process of forming analogous elites continues to this day, even amid enormous social, political, economic, and cultural transformations. This point is critical, since the very concept of a nobility seems archaic to many contemporary readers." (Nobility and Analogous Traditional Elites, American Appendix, p. 141.)
Print Friendly
Share