Destructive Indifference or Destructive Irreverence?

January 19, 2026

Considering this photograph, the reader gifted with an artistic sense will surely sense the violent contrast in it. This monumental pulpit, crowned by a canopy with noble and elegant lines that confer upon it a princely quality, dates from the eighteenth century and is part of the parish church of La Ferté-sur-Aube in France. But there could be no greater contrasting deviation from this solemn assemblage than the electric fan that was recently placed on it. This fan looks like a packing crate or a small model of a cement building designed for our times. It is the very opposite of the delicacy, elegance and solemnity of the décor to which it was added. To use a French expression the fan and the pew “hurlent de se trouver ensemble,” howl upon finding themselves together.

In a sadly eloquent way, this juxtaposition expresses the indifference, if not irreverence, in many churches today that is taking place ‒ in France as well as in the rest of the world ‒ the “aggiornamento*.”

*Aggiornamento roughly means bringing up-to-date, updating or modernizing.

 Ambience Customs & Civilization“Catolicismo” no. 192 ― December 1966

 

Share

Previous post: